My daughter tells me that she walked out of it. I stayed to the bitter end, playing hooky at a near empty IMAX theater, all the way to the final credits when a bad live performance of the song off the
Exile on Main Street album that gave the film its title played, and only in a brief fragment. Here's its refrain, which I have always thought was ironic, the clue (in addition to the vocalist's melodramatic delivery) being "evening sun", because why "evening", and not "morning"?
May the good lord shine a light on you
Make every song your favourite tune
May the good lord shine a light on you
Warm like the evening sun
Martin Scorcese's documentary film of a Rolling Stones concert in a small New York City theater
Shine a Light. One newspaper review I read was enthusiastic, another one, so so. I agreed with the latter. Scorcese, in an interview with the local newspaper, admitted that the film contained predominantly close ups. That was the first sign of trouble. There were others. The less than positive review noted that the director had used 18 cameras, and, the reviewer added, 17 of them must have been pointed at Mick Jagger. Indeed, the film consists pretty much of two hours of close ups of Mick Jagger prancing with the agility of a twenty year old.
"How could the Rolling Stones agree to this?" asks my daughter. All four are listed as "Executive Producers", who, one guesses, financed the film and will pocket some if not most of the profits. I admit that after the first half hour of the film I was considering walking out, my senses tired of the constant movement of the cameras, short, MTV editing cuts, and the proximity of the screen, as in an IMAX auditorium, which is taller than deeper, you cannot ever sit far from the screen. But, you can say, I suffered through it, so you don't have to, and in the end prevailed long enough to note Albert Maysles' name in the credits!
Interspersed throughout the film are fragments of old interviews with the current members of the Rolling Stones (ignoring the one who died and the two who quit), like the rest of the film, nothing revelatory. The band is introduced by a former president of the United States, who manages to insinuate himself into everything these days, and, customarily, makes the whole affair seem as if it was all about himself. A former president of Poland is seen briefly in the background, too, and is being introduced to somebody by the other ex-president!
There are guest stars, Jack White, Christina Aguilera, and Buddy Guy, who, despite their best efforts, manage to detract very little from the Rolling Stones, Jack filling the high notes that Mick can no longer hit, Christina, whoever she is, prancing like a Las Vegas go-go girl, and Buddy, whom my daughter liked very much, playing mostly a two note riff on an old Muddy Waters classic
Champagne and Reefer and walks away with a Gibson guitar presented to him by Keith Richards.
When Mick puts on a Fender Telecaster and the band launches into a three guitar attack on
Some Girls, you can hear why they are so powerful as a band. Later, Keith sings solo
You Got the Silver, with Ronnie on slide, another highlight of the show.
But the sidemen, some of who, like saxophonist Bobby Keys have been with the band for decades, or like keyboardist Chuck Lovell are the musical director of the band, are ignored by the cameras, and the band as a whole is ignored by the camera of a director, who, in my opinion doesn't get the idea of what rock and roll is about. Bernard Fowler, the backup vocalist has been with them for at least twenty years, another backup vocalist Blondie Chaplin plays an accoustic guitar in the background, and has previously been a latter day member of the Beach Boys and some other prominent bands.
Last weekend, I was talking with a friend about the first rock and roll films from the 1950s, such as
Don't Knock the Rock, with Bill Haley and the Comets, with bad scripts and story lines and lipsynching performers, but cameras focused on entire ensembles, not just on iconic stars. In
Shine a Light, Keith launches into
Connection, off a 1966 album
Between the Buttons, originally sang by Mick
, and the clueless director keeps interrupting the song, interspersing it with cuts from some past interviews. Why?
But hey, you have to see the film for the final Orson Wellesian shot, a sort of reverse
Citizen Kane opening, helped in large measure by modern computerized effects. Just don't ask what it means!
* * *
New Yorker magazine
review.